Stirling Cycle.

Two isothermals and two constant-volume legs joined by a regenerator — and with a perfect one it reaches the Carnot limit.

Mode

The machine — Two isothermals and two constant-volume legs joined by a regenerator — and with a perfect one it reaches the Carnot limit.

Diagram
2.04.06.08.0101214161820220204060801001→2: Isothermal expansion, absorbing heat2→3: Constant-volume cooling into the regenerator3→4: Isothermal compression, rejecting heat4→1: Constant-volume heating from the regenerator1State 1 — Hot, minimum volume2State 2 — Isothermal expansion complete3State 3 — Cooled through the regenerator4State 4 — Isothermal compression completeSpecific volume vPressure P

Press Run to turn the machine over. Space runs and pauses, R resets, and the arrow keys step through the cycle one process at a time.

isothermal 1→2 · Isothermal expansion, absorbing heat q 0 w 537.1 kJ/kg

Thermal efficiency

66.67%

Carnot limit, same span

66.67%

Net work

358.1 kJ/kg

Heat added

537.1 kJ/kg

Heat rejected

179 kJ/kg

Peak temperature

900 K

Lowest temperature

300 K

Mean effective pressure

19.8 kPa

Every setting is inside its sensible range for this cycle. Push a slider to an extreme and anything worth knowing about will appear here.

State points — the cycle, one corner at a time

State What just happened P kPa v m³/kg T K s kJ/kg·K
1 Hot, minimum volume 100 2.583 900 1.104
2 Isothermal expansion complete 12.5 20.664 900 1.7
3 Cooled through the regenerator 4.2 20.664 300 0.912
4 Isothermal compression complete 33.3 2.583 300 0.315

Isothermal expansion · Constant-volume cooling through the regenerator · Isothermal compression · Constant-volume heating from the regenerator

Starting points Pick one, then move any slider from there.

The textbook case. With every joule handed back on the heating leg, this cycle reaches the Carnot limit exactly — one of only two here that can.

8
900 K
300 K
1

How the Stirling cycle works

The Stirling cycle takes its working fluid through 4 processes and returns it to the state it began in. In order, those are:

  1. Isothermal expansion
  2. Constant-volume cooling through the regenerator
  3. Isothermal compression
  4. Constant-volume heating from the regenerator

You will find it in submarine power, cryocoolers, solar dishes. At the standard set-up above — volume ratio 8, hot reservoir 900 K, cold reservoir 300 K, regenerator effectiveness 1 — it reaches a thermal efficiency of 66.67%, against a Carnot limit of 66.67% for the same temperature span. The net work is 358.1 kJ/kg, from 537.1 kJ/kg of heat in and 179 kJ/kg rejected.

Its efficiency has a closed form: η → 1 − T_C/T_H as ε → 1. The simulator above does not use it — it solves the state points and divides net work by heat in — but the two agree to machine precision, and the test suite behind this page checks that on every build.

Reading the two diagrams

Switch the diagram pane between P–v and T–s and watch the same cycle change costume. On the pressure–volume plot the area inside the loop is the net work per kilogram of working fluid, because work is the integral of P dv. On the temperature–entropy plot the area inside the loop is the net heat, because heat in a reversible process is the integral of T ds.

Those two areas are the same number. That is the first law applied to a closed loop: the fluid ends where it started, so its internal energy has not changed, so everything that went in as heat came out as work. Two different pictures, one arithmetic.

The T–s view is the more revealing of the two once you are comfortable with it, because it shows the temperature at which heat crossed the boundary — and that, not the amount, is what decides how much of it can become work.

A minister’s answer to exploding boilers

Robert Stirling, a Scottish clergyman, patented his engine in 1816. The motivation was safety: the steam boilers of the period burst regularly and killed people, and Stirling’s engine used a sealed charge of air heated from outside, with no high-pressure steam anywhere in it.

The patent’s real contribution was not the engine layout but the regenerator — a mesh or matrix that the working gas passes through in both directions, storing heat on the way out and giving it back on the way in. It is one of the most elegant ideas in engineering and it is the whole of this cycle.

The regenerator is the cycle

Set regenerator effectiveness to 1 above and the efficiency card and the Carnot card read the same number. That is the remarkable property: with perfect regeneration, this cycle reaches the theoretical maximum for its temperature span, using two isothermal legs and two constant-volume ones.

Now drag effectiveness to 0 and watch it collapse. Without the regenerator, all the constant-volume heat has to come from the burner instead of from storage, and the cycle loses most of its advantage. Between those extremes is where every real Stirling engine lives, and it explains why they are hard: the regenerator must have enormous surface area, low flow resistance and low thermal mass all at once.

Why they are wonderful and rare

A Stirling engine burns nothing internally, so it will run on any heat source at all — a burner, concentrated sunlight, radioisotopes, waste heat. It is quiet, because there is no exhaust event. It is clean, because combustion happens continuously outside at whatever conditions you choose.

It is also heavy for its power, slow to change output, and dependent on heat exchangers that are expensive to make well. Sealing a light working gas like helium or hydrogen at pressure for thousands of hours is its own problem. So they turn up where those drawbacks do not matter and the advantages do: submarine air-independent propulsion, cryogenic coolers running the cycle backwards, and solar dish generators.

Stirling cycle — common questions

How can a real cycle reach the Carnot efficiency?

Because with an ideal regenerator, the heat exchanged on the two constant-volume legs never crosses the cycle boundary at all — it moves into storage and back out again. Only the two isothermal legs exchange heat with the outside world, and a cycle whose external heat exchange is entirely isothermal at two temperatures is a Carnot cycle in disguise.

What does the regenerator actually do?

It is a matrix of fine wire, foil or porous material that the gas flows through in both directions. Cooling gas gives up heat to it; heating gas takes that heat back. The burner then only has to supply the isothermal heat, not the constant-volume heat as well. Set effectiveness to 0 above to see what happens without it.

Where are Stirling engines actually used?

Submarine air-independent propulsion, where running without an exhaust matters more than power density; cryocoolers, which run the cycle in reverse to reach very low temperatures; and solar dish generators, where a concentrator supplies the hot end. They are also popular as demonstration engines because they will run on a cup of hot water.

Why is it called an external combustion engine?

Because the working gas is sealed in and heated through a wall, rather than being the combustion products themselves. That is what lets it run on any heat source, and what makes its combustion clean — the burner operates continuously at steady conditions instead of in violent intermittent bursts.

All tools